Both of Them, Only Her
Two husbands, one woman, and a love built entirely on the door staying open—while a stalker tries to slam it shut.
Kate Marsh, a foster-care-raised English student working an arena concession stand and a used bookshop, meets Rowan Ashby and Declan Voss—the first openly married pair of active hockey players—when they yield the moment she names an exit rather than crowd her.
Their courtship proceeds by explicit consent, clear boundaries, and a refusal to convert their money or fame into leverage, and Kate slowly agrees to date both husbands at once.
When a hostile opposing player escalates from on-ice intimidation to anonymous threats, a fabricated betting-fraud ledger, and coercive surveillance, the three must protect one another through lawyers, security protocols, and evidence rather than by taking away Kate’s autonomy.
The relationship’s survival hinges on whether they can meet danger without any one of them being contained or spoken for.
Tropes: why-choose / MMF ménage, established M/M couple opens their marriage, hockey romance, age gap, wealth disparity / Cinderella dynamic, consent-forward courtship, cinnamon-roll enforcer, protector heroes who defer to the heroine’s agency, romantic suspense / stalker antagonist, found family, forced proximity (snowed-in finale)
📖 Read the first chapter free
Story promises: Guaranteed HEA · multiple POV · past tense (what this means)
Content notes: explicit consensual sexual content; stalking; assault; coercive control; extortion / blackmail; public harassment; sports violence; foster-care background; panic attacks / trauma responses (full index)
More from Lady Heartswell

A Kiss for the Knife
She brought a knife to kill him. Keeping him alive may cost her everything.
Man Advantage
They are the kings of the ice. The NHL’s most violent, exclusive couple. And they just decided I’m the only thing holding them together.
Man Advantage 9
Her father taught her that obedience was safety. Two brutal hockey stars make her want a freedom sharp enough to bite.
